This or All-of-That: for $380

One of the age old question between girlfriends: Would you rather have one investment piece or lots of other less expensive pieces for the same price. Discuss.

My hypothetical "would you rather" below!

Giles and Brother Sorceress Collar $380

Vs.

Forever 21 Vibrant Braided Necklace $8.80

Lauren Elan Rhys bracelet $45

Monserat De Lucca Origami Necklace $62 

Odette New York Ojos Eye Cuff $164

Cheap Monday Elongate Ring $20

Club Monaco Harper Necklace $79.50