This or All-of-That: for $380

One of the age old question between girlfriends: Would you rather have one investment piece or lots of other less expensive pieces for the same price. Discuss.

My hypothetical "would you rather" below!

Giles and Brother Sorceress Collar $380

Vs.

Forever 21 Vibrant Braided Necklace $8.80

Lauren Elan Rhys bracelet $45

Monserat De Lucca Origami Necklace $62 

Odette New York Ojos Eye Cuff $164

Cheap Monday Elongate Ring $20

Club Monaco Harper Necklace $79.50

Which would you rather: For $735

Would you rather one, big ticket item or many items for the same price?

Your choice (if you choose to accept):

- one Diamond Filigree Necklace for $735

OR

- one Two-Headed Snake Ring
- one Ampersand Ring
- one Ojos Eye Cuff
- one Mini Bar Ring
- one pair of Gemma Redux earrings
- set of Marc by Marc Jacobs Jelly bracelets
for $736

Vote in the comments below! 

Which Would You Rather: for $545

I can never decide if it's better to invest in pricier but more quality pieces or to get the most bang for my buck and choose quantity over quality. There are so many pieces that I would love to own that are just out of my price range. But if I saved up and stop buying cheaper pieces I would be able to buy fewer, but more expensive pieces. I am not totally sure which is better, and like most things, it probably depends on the situation. If there is an expensive piece of jewelry you're in love with and know you'll get a lot of use out of, you'll probably save up. For trendier pieces I am guessing most of you would choose cheaper options.

But let's get specific. Would you rather this Gemma Redux necklace for $545.00 or eight pieces for the same price?

Gemma Redux, Cordelia Necklace, $545
------- Or -------
J. Crew, OGJM azalea bracelet, $74
ASOS, Aztec Triangle Drop Earrings, $13.26
J. Crew, Crystal Cupcake Necklace, $138
J. Crew, Classic Link Bracelet, $102
ASOS, Multi Chain Rounded Collar Necklace, $19.88
Shashi, Neon Nugget Bracelet, $22
Frieda and Nellie, Ravishing Rodeo bracelet, $160
ASOS, Spike Stretch Bracelet, $13.26
+ a cup of coffee = $545


Let me know in the comments below which you would choose!